by Dreams End » Thu Sep 15, 2005 11:08 am
Wow, always amazed at the posts on this site and this thread is inspiring.<br><br>I am sorry, maggrwaggr, that your question didn't get answered. Definitely focusing on me at the moment. DID used to be called Multiple Personality Disorder. the basic idea, if you didn't want to read the wikipedia article, is that trauma in childhood can lead to dissociative states. You've had dissociative states yourself, most likely, such as when you drive for a bit, realized you've zoned out and have no actual memory of driving for the last five minutes. Some are more prone to this. In the midst of trauma, such dissociation can be so severe that a "separate" personality can split off. It's actually a creative survival strategy, but as an adult it can interfere with your life rather dramatically...especially if some of the alters are into destructive behavior. <br><br>I'll call my wife Donna, at Avalon's suggestion (I'd just been thinking the same thing, actually). Donna is fairly co-conscious...that is to say, that usually, even if an alter is "out" she remembers most of what is going on. She has actually always described the "man with the camera" who sits back and sort of comments on what's going on. She later realized that she was the man with the camera while alters were out! <br><br>Avalon also suggests that the suppository episodes might have been indeed as traumatic as recalled by the parents. It's possible...though no matter what a bad pediatrician might suggest, I would certainly not have continued such "treatment". And I'm pretty sure that the "holding down" part would not have been done without loss of temper because a)her Dad is known to have one and I imagine alters of her Mom do as well and b) Donna has an angry alter named Spike...let's just say you don't want to trigger Spike. Unfortunately, Spike is primarily triggered by rebellious behavior by her daughter. <br><br>I also, despite being fairly left brained, have an intuitive side. Intuitively speaking, there's some definite wrongness from Donna's childhood. And I think the fact that her Mom is DID really shows a family system at work here. But what it means and exactly what happened...well, yes, sw, we may never know exactly and healing is the thing to focus on. <br><br>I let Project Willow know, in a private email, that Donna's system does not seem to be as complex as many of the RA/MC abuse survivors. That, and the fact that I've probed her history as discretely as I can for evidence that there is something more than simply family abuse (not that this is a good thing) and so far, I see no reason to suspect any more "formalized" abuse. (I shared in another post that she had lived with her family in Italy as a child. She read "Sinister Forces" and came across the name of a General who was in the middle of all kinds of intelligence stuff and said, "Oh, this is the general who lived across from us in Rome." Shit! However, a simple Google revealed this this guy died before she was even born. )<br><br> However, if memories of such behavior did emerge, I would certainly not have a problem believing her. The one thing that did make me a little suspicious, however, is that after her Dad got the message that she wasn't able or willing to talk to him, he would call every week at exactly the same time. We never answered but he'd keep calling. Having read so often about "trigger words", this made me a little nervous. Still, I'm not going to assume that there is more to this than is needed to explain what's going on. She has enough to worry about. If such memories emerge on their own, we'll deal with it. For now, she rarely talks to her Dad...in fact the only reason she did so recently was a funeral of her grandfather, whom she loved dearly. It almost put her in the hospital, but I went to the funeral with her and we got through it. We both now wonder if that had been worth it, but had she not gone, I think her doubts would have been much greater. I also NEVER let her out of my site, which I think creeped Donna's sister out, but whatever. It was very important to her that she not get stuck with her dad alone. <br><br>Sorry for such a long post. Let me also mention that we talked last night and there are just some things going on that are triggering memories from Donna's last marriage and this is one reason she's seemed a bit irrational...that is, arguing about things that don't make sense (to me, anyway). I think we are in better shape now. I also read Whisper a story last night (and, sw, told her about Space and she was quite interested and thought maybe they could play hopscotch together!) and so I think we are okay. Whisper is the only alter I have a relationship with so I don't know how the rest of her system is feeling, but I think the crisis has passed. Thanks to all of you for allowing me to vent. I realize this is not a psychological help forum and that, given how the nature of conversations can go on this site, I don't think we should encourage it in that direction. But I took the liberty of sharing all this and was really thankful at all the remarks, encouragement and good advice.<br><br>If anyone has read this far, let me end with remarks in an email to me from my friend who is a therapist about the original subject of this thread, Dr. Martinez. I think it's interesting and rather validating:<br><br> <!--EZCODE QUOTE START--><blockquote><strong><em>Quote:</em></strong><hr> I will be honest in my appraisal of what I read about this therapist. Such political views would have to influence his practice, and to think otherwise would be naive. He sounds like a grandiose narcissist. His opinions are framed as facts, and I would bet that his research methodology, if indeed there is any research (He refers to having "studied" the effects of retaliation on the immune system), is the kind of pseudoscience that appeals to people who are mistrustful of real science. What he is suggesting is, in my view, so complex that it would be very hard, if possible, to generalize as liberally as he does about retaliation and health. The truth is, "an eye for an eye" type of thinking would be a good way to spread ever-increasing amounts of post traumatic stress disorder further and create future generations of violent and vengeful people around the globe. I'll have to admit, his message is one that can draw audiences in these times. Hitler did the same in his time (Read Alice Miller's book, For Your Own Good).<br> We know that laughing is good for the immune system. So, maybe I should generalize as well and start encouraging my clients to laugh at terrorists. <br> There is a lot of nonsense out there, especially in my profession, and such bullshit can cause harm. I'm glad that you are not going to see him. <hr></blockquote><!--EZCODE QUOTE END--><br><br>Well said, I thought. <br><br><br><br> <p></p><i></i>