jlaw said:
Your relative probably recalls periods of unrest where Copts were scapegoated by Muslims to satiate the masses. Scapegoating minorities is a very common political occurrence and is as old as time. It was very common to trump up charges, place people in custody, and then confiscate their wealth. This has been done to Jews for centuries by both Christian and Muslim regimes.
My relative has 2000 years to choose from, to support his narrative of persecution. No matter what he was looking for, he'd likely find it. Moreover, with his paranoia ramped up as it is, a less-than-friendly look or a business-related conflict can easily become emotionally conflated with a bloody 'pogrom' that supposedly took place in some village during the 11th century. It's called confirmation bias.
What I find most peculiar is that in real life he doesn't seem to think much of his fellow Copts either (as opposed to the Platonic idea he nurtures, of the "bleeding Copt"). Though you'd think that was an aberration, I've found that most people who hold racist views about others tend to hold rather unflattering views of their "own kind" as well. In his case, I attribute that to unresolved emotional and psychological issues, but then he's not made a career out of stoking and profiting from the fears of his fellow Copts, as so many others, who are little more than con artists, have.
Partly, this is related to the fact that predators most often prey on "their own kind" with a greater expectation of getting away with it, which they frequently do because of the fear of airing 'our' dirty laundry or causing 'our enemies' to gloat.
With obvious differences, I see parallels between that sort of attitude and the deep contempt with which some zionist leaders view other Jews. These individuals make quite a name for themselves, and a fortune as well, promoting a siege mentality and issuing dark warnings of an imminent Holocaust, while, like foxes in the hen-house crying about the wolf at the door, callously rip off the same Jews whom they claim to want to protect from the anti-semitic world. Meir Kahane comes to mind, as does Ariel Sharon, among many others; stripped of their carefully-nurtured aura as Heroic Defenders of the Jews, their actions make it clear that they considered Jews as meat. It's no accident that both were prone to make extremely hostile generalizations and use ethnic slurs that wouldn't sound out of place coming out of the mouth of the most rabid anti-semite, at least (but not always) in private.
These people are dangerous, not only because they are ruthless opportunists and predators, but also because they help to create self-fulfilling prophecies. With regard to the Copts, I'm thinking of a certain Maurice Sadek, who's made a lucrative career for himself fabricating and/or vastly exaggerating incidents of religious persecution of Copts by Muslims in Egypt. In the U.S., he received refugee status and then citizenship based on such false claims; since then, he's made his fortune fabricating similar claims for Copts seeking a fast track to legal status in the U.S. -- for a hefty fee, naturally.
Maurice Sadek specializes in publicizing sensational accounts of Coptic persecution: Copts nailed to crosses, girls kidnapped, raped and forced to convert to Islam, massacres by Muslim mobs; no claim is too wild or baseless that it won't be picked up and spread by unscrupulous or gullible media and certain political elements. Coptic community and church leaders in Egypt protest in vain that these stories are false, and independent investigations by international human rights organizations which prove them to be serious distortions, are ignored.
His relentless campaign over the past few decades, picked up and propelled by fundamentalist Christian and other zionist elements, has fueled fears among some Egyptian Muslims of a global conspiracy against them, in which "the Copts" are suspected to be complicit, a sort of fifth column. In a move clearly calculated to fuel such dangerous ideas, a few years ago Sadek openly admitted, to an Egyptian tv audience of millions over the telephone from the States, that he'd sent a letter to Israeli Prime Minister Ariel Sharon (aka "the butcher"), begging him to "save" the Copts. I heard him with my own ears.
To me, Maurice Sadek is the very incarnation of zionism -- if he were a character in a novel, he'd be its archetype, cynically trying to provoke, promote and profit from the very persecution he claims to be fighting. Because of this background, I am confident that if I were Jewish, I would still despise the zionists as much as I currently despise and fear their Coptic counterparts, as a dangerous enemy disguised as a defender. Not surprisingly, there have been persistent rumors since the 1970s that some of these "Coptic zionists" are secretly plotting with their Jewish counterparts to divide Egypt into three mini-states, a Sunni one in the north, a Coptic one in the south, and a Nubian one in the deep south. Though they deny it strenuously, other individuals have reported that this is part of a long-term strategy that is being kept under wraps until circumstances make it more palatable for Copts in Egypt, perhaps in the wake of "a new Pearl Harbor", Egyptian-style or, more appropriately, "a Holocaust" just like the one that led to the creation of Israel. Such speculation was reinforced by the publication of an infamous essay in the journal of the World Zionist Organization in 1982, by an Israeli Foreign Ministry official, Oded Yinon, entitled "A Strategy for Israel in the 1980s", which argued that such a division of Egypt would serve Israel's interests very well, and should be pursued.
In any case, while it is tempting for some to fight anti-semitism, anti-Coptism or any other kind of tribal-type 'racism' with its tribal mirror image, it is a highly malignant temptation, far more likely to lead to a spiral of hatred and violence that endangers all us chickens, and profits only the foxes. It is my personal experience, one which is borne out by my own forays into historical investigation, that perceptions of both "love" and "hate" tend to be self-fulfilling prophecies. Injustice can never be defeated by more injustice, but by devoting all our common mental and physical energy to the creation of mechanisms that can guarantee and enforce equal justice for all.
"If you're not careful the newspapers will have you hating the oppressed and loving the people doing the oppressing." - Malcolm X