Moderators: Elvis, DrVolin, Jeff
I did pull back from this thread on first reading, uncomfortably close to the assertions that bad guys are the way they are because of Mom etc I thought.
Joe Hillshoist wrote:Many intelligent observations and criticisms....
yathrib wrote:I'm a woman, but there are few things that piss me off more than the assertion that women taking over would make the world kinder and gentler. Think Margaret Thatcher. Ann Coulter. The official fascist shrew of the Republicrat party, Hillary Clinton. I could go on.
Some of the most reactionary, militaristic people I've ever met are women, and I refuse to believe that *all* of them are brainwashed by the patriarchy.
When it doesn't happen, perhaps we can do away with such foolish sexist pablum and try to make real change.
John E. Nemo wrote:[see above]
FourthBase wrote:Here's the PM:From: FourthBase
To: Jeff
Posted: 20 Oct 2007 22:33
Subject: Every thread turns into an argument
And I'm not just talking about the ones I lose my temper in, lol, I'm talking about every thread. Now I know argument and debate and "agon" is healthy and productive. But so is the occasional discussion among like-minded people, which is IMPOSSIBLE on this site. Discussions amongst friends in a living room over a bong and a bottle of wine...think of how many great conversations people have in that kind of environment. There's some debate, sure -- but so much of the talk is people who fundamentally agree on premises helping each other figure shit out, not constantly correcting and bickering and drowning out each other. Have you thought anymore about subforums where you'd schedule restricted access for an invited group of posters depending on the subject? Nothing hidden or out of sight, for everyone to see, but only a select few to contribute to. Fuck the charges of elitism that would be sure to follow, the proof will be in the pudding, i.e., great threads, lively threads, threads that last for a long time but amazingly don't wind up in a pissing match between two loudmouths. You feeling me Jeff? Is that setup possible?
Working in an office or sitting in a quad or sitting around a dinner table, it's possible for a group of people to talk with each other about something they generally agree about. If somebody walks by and butts in and says "I completely disagree" and goes on to argue that the premise of the conversation is bullshit...then the group of people have the freedom to walk away and resume the conversation elsewhere or another time, or worst case scenario say "Get lost asshole, we're having a conversation" and shoo the arguer away. That's not possible here (or on any internet forum I guess). What I'm proposing is a way to make it possible, to allow for a conversation other than a balls-out argument over everything including the basics of a subject. Maybe it's a radical idea, I don't know. I think not, though, since it's basically just the forum version of a roundtable discussion that we see "distinguished" people get to participate in all the time. This thread was the last fucking straw for me. Instead of being able to talk about this subject with the several people here who I'm sure agree with me more or less, and have an evolving conversation that would probably include the same exceptions and points of argument but without the total disavowal of the validity of the entire fucking subject...I'm trapped by the trappings of a "public forum" and forced to respond to people I have no interest in discussing this with, which severely limits if not precludes the kind of discussion I wanted.
Every American male I know between the ages of 18-34, were forcibly removed from their homes when they turned 18 and forced to fend for themselves.
Every American female I know of the same age group was given a free ride through college, with both tuition and rent paid by their parents.
Most, if not all, females were bought automobiles by the same parents, who also paid for their insurance and gave them credit cards for gasoline.
The males I know were given none of this.
American males are being treated as second-class citizens by a society that feels that, in the words of one parent I know "My son can sleep in his car, but not my daughter."
Why are there over-populated nations with people starving to death?
Obviously poor people don't have access to birth control, but when you boil it all down it's because men can't control their need to get laid and woman can't control their urges to have babies.
Why is there so much suburban sprawl?
Women want to raise their families in nice, quiet, crime-free areas.If that means ravaging the countryside and increasing pollution, then so be it.
Why are there SUVS?
So soccer moms can achieve status amongst their peers by driving their broodlings in the most expensive gas-wasting thing that Detroit marketed specifically to them.
Why are there sweatshops and Walmarts?
So women can buy cheap things for their families. Ask yourself whose idea it was to get married and have babies in the first place? It's rarely the man's idea, in my experience.
But Sunny, Sunny, Sunny, never forget who the TRUE victims are:
men.
AlicetheKurious wrote:Populistindependent, your post is a masterpiece ....
brekin wrote:I had an interesting experience working for a large non-profit that was 99.9% female. The YWCA (Young Womens Christian Association). I and one other male (the tech guy) were the only males in our branch, and throughout the overall organization for the city.
I have to say the daily power struggles and turf wars that I witnessed were equivalent, if not at times more so, then what I've encountered in other more male dominated jobs (construction project management.) Really the difference that stands out for me probably was the difference in jokes.
A few co-workers in fact I thought represented the victim-perpertrator cycle very well. Having a huge reservoir of unresolved rage did not make them the most empathetic of people to be around.
I remember one co-worker coming in to read to everyone through giggles the remarks of an unrepentant women on the witness stand who killed her husband.
Users browsing this forum: No registered users and 170 guests