Hastert told authorities he was extorted by alleged abuse victim Former U.S. House Speaker Dennis Hastert
Former U.S. House Speaker Dennis Hastert through the years.
Jason MeisnerContact Reporter
Chicago Tribune
Federal prosecutors gave new details in a lengthy court filing Friday night about allegations of sex abuse against former U.S. House Speaker Dennis Hastert, saying he told authorities that one man had extorted him for $3.5 million.
Prosecutors said Hastert's life was a "stunning hypocrisy."
Reflecting on his career as a wrestling coach, prosecutors noted that Hastert wrote in his memoir that there was "never a sufficient reason to strip away a person's dignity."
"Yet that is exactly what he did to his victims," prosecutors wrote in the 26-page filing. "He made them feel alone, ashamed, guilty and devoid of dignity. While (Hastert) achieved great success, reaping all the benefits that went with it, these boys struggled, and all are still struggling now with what (he) did to them."
PDF: Prosecutors' position on Dennis Hastert sentencing
The court filing revealed that after an initial interview of Hastert in December 2014 by law enforcement, he later told authorities that he was the victim of an extortion plot by a person identified only as Individual A. Hastert had agreed to pay $3.5 million to Individual A to keep quiet about misconduct decades ago.
Prosecutors also disclosed that federal agents listened in on conversations as Hastert talked by telephone to Individual A.
The prosecution memo comes two days after Hastert's lawyers filed court papers seeking probation for the former lawmaker. The defense filing said Hastert was "profoundly sorry" for the harm he caused others decades ago but stopped short of acknowledging accusations he sexually abused students at Yorkville High School. In fact, his lawyers singled out his teaching and coaching background for praise, saying he chose that career path "to make a difference in the lives of young people."
Hastert pleaded guilty in October to a felony count of illegally structuring cash withdrawals to evade bank currency-reporting requirements, but underlying that dry charge were the bombshell allegations that Hastert had agreed to pay $3.5 million to a person identified only as Individual A to keep quiet about misconduct decades ago.
Dennis Hastert accused of sexual abuse by at least 4, sources say
On Thursday, the Tribune reported that at least three other people in addition to Individual A have made what law enforcement sources said are credible allegations of sexual abuse against Hastert. The newspaper has determined the identities of three of them, all men, whose allegations stretch over a decade when they were teenagers and Hastert was their coach.
One is dead, but his sister, Jolene Burdge, has long spoken out about the details she said her brother, Stephen Reinboldt, shared with her before his death from AIDS in 1995. He was an equipment manager for the school's wrestling and football teams before graduating in 1971. Burdge said she plans to read a victim-impact statement at Hastert's sentencing, scheduled for April 27.
Another alleged victim, identified in court as Individual D, also may address the court at Hastert's sentencing. Individual D has talked to the Tribune at length but has not agreed to be named.
The Tribune has also learned the identity of Individual A, but he declined to talk to reporters.
The victim testimony could prove crucial in determining whether Hastert gets prison time.
Dennis Hastert accusations
Jolene Burdge poses at her home in Billings, Mont. She said her brother, Stephen Reinboldt, was sexually abused by former U.S. House Speaker Dennis Hastert when Reinboldt was a student and Hastert was a wrestling coach and teacher at Yorkville High School.
His plea agreement with prosecutors recommends a sentence ranging from probation to up to six months in prison — the lowest possible sentence under federal guidelines for a felony conviction. U.S. District Judge Thomas M. Durkin has noted, however, that he is free to sentence Hastert to up to five years in prison.
In their filing Wednesday, Hastert's attorneys recounted his rise from humble beginnings as a small-town schoolteacher to the longest-serving Republican House speaker in U.S. history. His "swift and devastating" fall from grace after his bombshell indictment in 2015 left him in a "state of despair caused by extreme isolation and the withdrawal of support from many friends and former colleagues," the filing stated.
The media frenzy that followed left Hastert's reputation in tatters, his lawyers said. Television news trucks camped out for days on the lawn of Hastert's Plano, Ill., home, helicopters circled overhead and reporters even followed his family members to Wisconsin when they tried to escape the intense scrutiny, according to the filing.
As he awaited trial in virtual hiding, Hastert's portrait was removed from the U.S. Capitol, he was forced to withdraw from numerous boards and institutions, and the tightknit community that had long been his base of support turned against him, his lawyers said.
"Mr. Hastert knows that the days of him being welcomed in the small towns he served all of his life are gone forever," the filing said. "He knows that, for the rest of his life, wherever he goes, the public warmth and affection that he previously received will be replaced by hostility and isolation."
Hastert says he's 'deeply sorry' for misconduct decades ago
The filing also noted Hastert's fragile medical condition, saying he nearly died of a rare blood infection during his first week in a hospital in November. For the first time, Hastert's lawyers in Wednesday's filing described a stroke he suffered in the hospital as a minor one.
Hastert, 74, often uses a wheelchair and needs assistance getting out of bed, going to the bathroom, bathing and dressing himself, the filing stated.
In advance of the sentencing, Durkin has appointed a doctor from Northwestern Memorial Hospital to review Hastert's health records, so the judge has an independent voice on the matter.
The statement issued by the defense outraged Burdge, 54, of Billings, Mont.
"Reading this makes me sick, almost like I did the wrong thing to a man who has 'done so much good for his community and country,'" she said. "It's so twisted."