Moderators: Elvis, DrVolin, Jeff
Thanks, for both your messages.
I don't like locking threads, but the issues raised by this one were just too entangled with personalities on the board. So, the way I saw it, to be fair I should either lock it, or ban outright the members called out by it. Locking was less drastic, and that's usually my choice.
Still, my intent isn't to stifle discussion, even heated, among members who care about this place. And thanks, btw, for being one of them.
I wrote:No problem, man. I was kinda gonna let Jeff handle that one, in case you were wondering why I hadn't replied.
I knew from your comments you wanted the thread to go on. And I have, as you might guess, a great deal of sympathy for your position and for brainpanhandler's. None of that's changed. It can be frustrating. But I hope you'll continue to post your comments in opposition to what you see as wrong-headed thinking when it strikes you to do so, as I for one find those comments consistently valuable.
wintler2 wrote:Thanks for your kind words. But i'm disinclined to consistently 'bring the fight' to those i consider offenders, as their hysterical abuse apparently suffices to end any discussion. There is elegant simplicity in just locking a thread but in this case it is rewarding the perpetrators, and i'm not idealistic enough to play against the house even if i know the rules mean i can't 'win'.
ciao. L
82_28 wrote:I'm glad you locked that thread. Not because of me or "for me", but because it is poisonous and I will not add to said poison. Do you know how many times, just in my line of work, I simply use the word "fucking" and everyone else does too? I never use "fucking" lightly, because nothing is light that is why I insert the word. I would never hurt anyone on this board ever. But I have had go arounds with wintler and BPH and I would prefer for them to stop. Do you know (obviously not) how many children and parents I work around? I would never talk like that around children. Do you know that I spoke to two different parents today about their beautiful babies as they were out and about and asked their babies' names? No, cos you weren't there (obviously and it's beside the point). I am heartfelt and am anti-grump. I tried to tell wintler over PM that I am cool and not to control the language I use through condescension. But Wintler had to go all insane on me for me telling him/her and providing "proof" that I have every right to write what I write and that if this is a "community" then he/she must curtail their visceral hatred for people who call them out and also use this "profanity" to do so.
I don't want to, but I may leave soon. We shall see. Too many mavens here that don't get language and its use. Language is meant to be used freely. One person's "potty mouth" is another's exclamation point. And all words should be welcomed besides the obvious racial ones (which our website attests to the use of all through the 20th century).
We need to have a grand RI meetup or something where we can see that we are all people, with eyes we can look into. I tell stories usually, shit that came to mind when the occurrence of the story happened. How I think about it now. I really don't give a fuck, really do not give a fuck, if how I write offends people. I am offended that some seek to control my language. This is never acceptable. I spend probably 95% of every I day I have off writing, here and when I'm trying to come up with book ideas. Among friends I say "fuck" this that and the other all the time. I consider RI to be a place of friends. Thus this is how I speak/write here.
But never, ever tell me I cannot use a certain word ever. Which is what BPH and wintler have been doing for some time.
Jeff wrote:I don't think you're a bad guy, and I'm glad you think of this as a place of friends. But I have to tell you, a lot of your friends have been telling us they feel your language to be verbally abusive. And I agree with them. I've given you a lot of latitude and many gentle reminders. If it persists, there are going to be consequences.
And don't tell me, or any other board admin for that matter, which posting rules you are determined to flout. That's not an argument you can win.
Users browsing this forum: No registered users and 2 guests