Allegro, thanks for posting that!
William D. Lindsay wrote:
And I have to muse: isn't it interesting that a conservative Republican Knight of Columbus at Penn State University, where Philip Jenkins, a professor of history and religious studies, a darling of the Catholic bishops and of Bill Donohue of the Catholic League, teaches, is now found to have replicated the behavior of the Catholic bishops in his response to the abuse of minors by someone under his authority?
Think he's overreaching. Reading the Grand Jury presentment, it is not clear how Paterno "replicated" the behavior of Catholic bishops. The presentment makes clear the following:
1. Paterno alerted his superior [Curley] shortly after Mcqueary reported to Paterno what Mcqueary had seen;
2. Schultz was called into a meeting with Paterno and Curley where Paterno reported "disturbing" and "inappropriate" conduct to Schultz. The characterization here are Schultz's characterizations. Schultz and Curley haven been arrested for lying to the Grand Jury about what McQueary told them [essentially, downplaying it].
SO, one cannot conclude from this that Paterno elided or minimized what had happened. Curley and Schultz KNEW what had happened, because McQueary had TOLD THEM HE SAW A CHILD BEING RAPED by Sandusky. Mcqueary told Paterno that as well, which I don't believe is in dispute. Curley and Schultz have been arrested because they lied [in the gran jury's estimation] about what McQueary told them.
Points being: Catholic bishops hushed up rape, and/or colluded with their superiors and charges to cover it up. Paterno MAY have done that, we don't know, but the grand jury presentment says he told his superiors, who came to know anyway b/c Paterno was responsible for putting them in touch w/ McQueary.
Also: Sandusky resigned in 1999, plainly because he was forced to after the 1998 incident generated that police reported which circulated on the PSU campus. Paterno was very likely the one who did that.
I am not claiming Paterno should not have been fired. OF COURSE he should have, and of course he should have gone to police [whatever that would have been worth]. I don't like him or what he stands for. But his behavior is not [yet to be known to be] the equivalent of the worst behavior of Catholic bishops.
Lindsey again:
But we live in a culture in which this scheme of entitlement is being given a run for its money in an unparalleled way, and so there is more and more pushback in many quarters when the seamy underside of patriarchal power and privilege is uncovered — as it is now being uncovered in the Herman Cain saga, in the story of Joe Paterno, and with the Catholic hierarchy around the world. As this process of pushback occurs, we’re going to continue to see badly educated young men who lean right politically —whose future is invested in patriarchy, or so they imagine— rioting in one way or another, either literally or metaphorically, as happened with some Penn State students last evening when Paterno’s firing was announced.
dead on.