Sadly accurate view of Occupy Knoxville from the Sunday business section of Our Local Daily
But when it comes to the Knoxville movement specifically, Cummings' daughter, Jasmine, may have summed it up best.
While her white Che Guevara T-shirt was an implicit challenge to the status quo, her small stature and tentative steps made for a decidedly nonthreatening persona.
The same could be said of Occupy Knoxville. While Nashville's Occupy encampment sparked a legal confrontation with the administration of Gov. Bill Haslam and members of Occupy Wall Street were recently forced out of a Manhattan park by police, Knoxville sympathizers have declined to camp out in public places and have cooperated with law enforcement.
Why the differing approaches?
Rose Hawley, a South Knoxville resident who has been active in the local movement, said Knoxville isn't New York or Nashville.
"They have the human resources to occupy (a location) 24-7," she said.
There may be more complex factors at work, though. Nathan Kelly, a University of Tennessee political scientist who has written a book about the politics of income inequality in the United States, said via email that the Occupy Wall Street message likely doesn't resonate broadly in Knoxville, which he described as a very conservative place.
[url][http://www.knoxnews.com/news/2011/nov/20/knoxvilles-occupation-takes-a-different-02/#comments/url]
I've avoided posting here or anywhere about my gut reaction to Occupy Knoxville because I know so much of it was totally unfair to Occupy. That is, I'm a burned out peace activist. I am bitter, suspicious tending to paranoid, and a general emotional mess.
When Occupy first began here, I spoke to one of the protesters gathering that evening for their first march. Even though I was bitchy -- telling him having leaders was a normal human condition, whether anyone has the grasp of reality to know it or not -- "tell me who's the alpha male here? who's the alpha female? Come on, it's standard primate biology and I can tell you're smart enough to know exactly what I mean ... " that little diatribe was unwarranted, and dear Iraq Vet Against the War, I'm sorry for being such a hysterical little bitch that night, but I'm old and bitter beyond even my belief. We ended up trading war stories. I told him a bit about DH's continuing bitterness over Vietnam. I told him DH was proud of all the Iraq vets with the sense to come home and try to stop that damned war. Before it was over, we were both a little teary, but yeah, I was a real bitch at first.
The following week, I met the people who were occupying downtown Knoxville 24/7, a little band of homeless people who'd decided that if they were going to be homeless, it was far better to be homeless with a point. I brought them food. I ate lunch with them twice. One of them was 19, epileptic, and pregnant and living on the street. I'm still worried about Kaylee. I told her that when I was 19, I was in full blown PTSD, homeless, and married to an insane revolutionary. (That so-called revolutionary is half the reason for my distrust of the left.)
Anyway, it's been illegal to fall asleep in a Knoxville public park for years. (The law against masks is, I suspect, an old anti-Klan law -- it's the case many places in the south, anyway. Something for all the Guy Fawkes fan to consider -- many American anti-mask laws were part of getting rid of the goddamned KKK. I lived in Georgia when it finally passed one of those laws. I wondered at the time when the time would come when it would be used against people with legit grievances.) So the homeless 24/7 protest folks did this. One of them had a car, so they had it parked where they could get to it. They'd protest and sleep in shifts.
I was so impressed with them that I decided I would actually come to an Occupy march. They changed the beginning time, so I missed it. I guess they announced that over twitter or something so I missed it. Hung out downtown until the GA finally began -- 30 to 40 people. It "smelled like Move On" to me, but I tried to argue away my misgivings. They announced they had no 24/7 presence. One of the homeless guys I'd been hanging out with had gotten drunk that day. He came up to the center of the meeting and started to roar incoherently. The Occupy enforcers dragged him off. I should have myself told them "I suspect he's pissed because you just denied that he and his friends exist, that they have been your 24/7 presence for the past week, and you just denied that they exist!"
During the GA, I stupidly signed up for one of the committees. During the meeting, I was having so many flash backs to so much stupid bullshit from the Left over my 50 years that I just got up and left. I realized that I was about to start shouting at people and possibly do great damage to something that had some real hope to it so matter how embittered I am personally. So I just got up and left.
Now they're in Our Local Daily bragging about how they're superior because they're not 24/7 and what a great relationship they have with the cops.
Personally, I'm not going to camp out. I think there are other ways to have the critically needed conversatins we've got to have to ever get anywhere. And I'm working on that, when not trying to simply make myself CALM THE &*(^% DOWN. But now Occupy Knoxville is distancing themselves from their homeless supporters , this implied criticism of their sisters and brothers in Nashville - I think I was right that day -- Occupy Knoxville really does smell one hell of a lot like Move On.