Moderators: Elvis, DrVolin, Jeff
AlicetheKurious wrote:compared2what? wrote:No, not directly. But he's a diehard defender of Israel's right to take those actions, which he sees as fully justified and necessary, in much the same way that torturing Algerians was back when he was personally engaged in doing exactly that...
Yes, and if so, then that's his opinion, one among many of his shitty opinions, which he, like everyone else, should have the right to express, because as I mentioned before, free speech is a human right.
compared2what? wrote:The leader of the French far-right party National Front (FN) has been named by four Algerian liberation war veterans as one of the persons involved in torturing them. While Le Pen admitted to torturing forty years ago, he now denies the charges and is to sue the daily newspaper 'Le Monde', which quoted the veterans.
'Le Monde' quotes one of four Algerians, Mohamed Abdellaoui, as saying that Le Pen in 1957 personally administered electric shocks. He beat me we an electric stick on the shoulders and on the knees," Abdellaoui remembered the treatment. A second Algerian veteran recalled Le Pen had "sit down on my body and forced me to drink water from the water closet."
[...]
Shortly after the war, the issue was less taboo, as the hatred was still strong. Also Le Pen at this time admitted he had participated in the torture of Algerian liberation fighters. "I tortured because it had to be done," he told the 'Combat' newspaper in 1962. Le Pen served in the Franco-Algerian war as a lieutenant in the paratrooper regiment, also in charge of intelligence.
...if that counts for anything, according to your moral calculus.
According to my moral calculus, torturing people is NOT a human right, but a severe VIOLATION of human rights, for which he should have been prosecuted and if found guilty, penalized harshly.
Alice wrote:But when he was finally prosecuted and convicted, it wasn't for torturing people, was it?
compared2what? wrote:Yes. He has said exactly that about the Palestinians.
See above: free speech is a human right. If it can be denied to certain people whose opinion you don't like, then it's not a right, but a privilege that is granted at the discretion of those who wield the power. Today it's people whose opinions you don't like, tomorrow it'll be you.
compared2what? wrote:Nothing about Jean-Marie Le Pen gives me a warm, fuzzy feeling, and I don't regard his conviction as good news.
But I do regard him as a bad, bad man.
So?
American Dream wrote:AlicetheKurious wrote: I believe the comments in question were posted here. It took about 2 minutes to find them.
So what is your current thinking about forming common cause with nazis, skinheads and others of that ilk?
Any different than it was before?
psynapz wrote:American Dream wrote:AlicetheKurious wrote: I believe the comments in question were posted here. It took about 2 minutes to find them.
So what is your current thinking about forming common cause with nazis, skinheads and others of that ilk?
Any different than it was before?
American Dream wrote:AlicetheKurious wrote:American Dream wrote:American Dream wrote:In a similar way, these vile racist, sexist, homophobic and otherwise reactionary militia and white supremacist groups should not be welcome in conspiracy culture, no matter how much they style themselves as outlaws...
Who said anything about "welcoming" them? Straw man.
I will never forget when you said you thought that it was perfectly fine to bring white supremacists into Palestinian solidarity groups.
The first thing that came to mind was:
"With friends like these, who needs enemies???"...
All these 'movements' share a deep, often justified, sense of grievance and an urgent need to do something now before it's too late. Beyond those commonalities, however, which in themselves are neither illegitimate nor wrong, I personally distinguish between movements I am prepared to support and those I am not, using these criteria...
Nothing could be better, from a systemic point of view, than to encourage each side to focus their anger on the other rather than on the system that oppresses both. It's no accident that racial hatred is being deliberately stoked by billionaire Rupert Murdoch's FOX network, or that racist incitement saturates so much of what passes for "entertainment" produced by Hollywood's elite "dream factory". Yet even a cursory understanding of human history, or the way the system is set up, would show that even if African-Americans were to entirely wipe out the white people who form the minions of the white supremacist movement or if the white supremacists were to wipe out all the Black people, it's hard to see how that would make any difference at all to the very real oppression that both groups face, of which the "color divide" is but one manifestation: a symptom, but not the disease itself.
Anyway, my point -- and I do have one -- is that we need to avoid the temptation to simplistically mirror these or similar supremacists' demonization of the Other, otherwise we help to perpetuate the very system that produces them. Whether we're talking about Jewish supremacists in Palestine or white supremacists in the U.S., mindlessly reacting in a way that reinforces their paranoia and self-pity is counterproductive. It is far more effective to distinguish between legitimate rights and aspirations while explicitly rejecting, exposing and counteracting their racist beliefs and their own violence or oppression of others.
It's also crucial to find a way to reach these people with accurate, relevant and verifiable information about the way the predatory system really works, including its formidable propaganda apparatus that is so effective at making people consistently act against their own self-interest. Although typically, such movements attract a number of seriously disturbed individuals, violent criminals and agents saboteurs, the majority are ordinary people who are bewildered and seeking the relief of trusting false prophets who claim to have all the answers. I'm not naive about how difficult it is to change racist attitudes, but I do believe that we should not be reinforcing the wall between "us" and "them", but instead hacking a doorway through that wall and providing a healthier, more informed and more intelligent alternative that strengthens OUR struggle for positive change, rather than THEIR struggle to keep society on its downward trajectory.
Peregrine wrote:In short, I didn't see her "welcoming white supremast groups with open arms" but focusing on knocking down the source of the true threat that perpetuates & enflames hatred of others. It's idealistic & I would love to see groups put away their hate of others & work towards something productive, but unfortunately, you're not going to get rid of ignorance & nowhere did I see her aligning with white supremasts or other hate-inspired groups, rather she pointed out their flaws.
American Dream wrote:I have also long been aware of the "new anti-Semitism" argument as a vehicle to stop Palestinian solidarity work in its tracks. Unfortunately- it works- as I have seen many, many times before.
AlicetheKurious wrote:American Dream wrote:I have also long been aware of the "new anti-Semitism" argument as a vehicle to stop Palestinian solidarity work in its tracks. Unfortunately- it works- as I have seen many, many times before.
I bet you have.
It doesn't work anymore, AD; people got wise. I doubt you'd find any Palestinian solidarity group willing to have you, or at least have you for long, once they figure out your m.o., which won't take long at all, judging by your performance here.
White supremacists accused of planning for 'race war' in Florida
By James Eng, msnbc.com
Members of a white supremacist skinhead group called American Front trained with AK-47s, shotguns and explosives at a fortified compound in central Florida to prepare for what its reputed leader believed to be an “inevitable race war,” prosecutors said Tuesday.
According to court documents, members of American Front discussed acts of violence that included causing “a disturbance” at City Hall in Orlando, shooting at a house and attacking an anti-racist skinhead group.
At least 10 members of the group, which authorities described as a militia-styled, anti-Semitic domestic terrorist organization, have been arrested in Florida since the weekend, including at least three people on Tuesday.
...
link:
http://usnews.msnbc.msn.com/_news/2012/ ... orida?lite
Users browsing this forum: No registered users and 158 guests